Instrumental music in Church Weddings

[longdistancerunner]

I remember the topic of whether people could use instrumental music at a wedding in a church. It was a tortured issue as many people had gone to the church their whole lives and wanted to be married there but also wanted some nice music at the wedding. What the elders said was we don't want anyone to see a piano being carried into the church, it will lead others astray. When people asked about something that you wouldn't see being carried into the church like a guitar or flute, they said it is just not proper, it would give the wrong appearance. The issue of either recorded vocal music or instrumental music was also brought up but I can't remember what the discussion about it was, but it was not permitted. I wonder what experiences others had with this. It was really an emotion issue for many.

I remember they did have a record player at the church to use for listening to recorded sermons. It was funny I was in a Sunday School class and somebody brought in a record about Noah's Ark, they didn't say this but it was a Bill Cosby comedy routine about Noah's ark. The teacher stopped the record.

With the liberal churches of Christ I see something interesting, they do not use instrumental music but will have it on the PA system before church services. However the somewhat strange thing I have seen at several is the song leader slapping his thighs for rhythm.

Here is a video of a tortured discussion about instrumental music which involves some really convoluted logic. I really like the topic brought up that we shouldn't be asking why instrumental music can't be used but rather why do some churches use it? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oGdTegYxF7M

[agricola]

If I recall correctly - back in the day (that is, a long time ago) the solution was to have weddings on any day BUT Sunday, and they would bring in a piano or small organ for the wedding, no problem EXCEPT NOT ON SUNDAY.
So weddings were Saturdays.

Because, you know, the church is not the BUILDING. It's just the church BUILDING, not the church!

[longdistancerunner]

If I recall correctly - back in the day (that is, a long time ago) the solution was to have weddings on any day BUT Sunday, and they would bring in a piano or small organ for the wedding, no problem EXCEPT NOT ON SUNDAY.
So weddings were Saturdays."

I wonder how many people were led astray and will spend eternity in hell by seeing a piano being rolled into the church of Christ?

[zeek]

I don't understand the coC's concern with leading anyone astray; by their doctrine, it really makes no difference. Everyone is going to hell anyway.

[B.H.]

The farmer in the dell
The farmer in the dell
At a wedding he used a pian-i-o
And when he died he went to hell

[DashRipRock]

The farmer in the dell
The farmer in the dell
At a wedding he used a pian-i-o
And when he died he went to hell

Good one B.H.

[agricola]

zeek's right. Seriously, if the CoC were even REMOTELY logical about things, they'd just drown people DURING baptism, so they would go straight to heaven, instead of chancing 'falling away' as soon as they got up. I mean, that is certainly the SAFEST thing!

[Ivy]

zeek's right. Seriously, if the CoC were even REMOTELY logical about things, they'd just drown people DURING baptism, so they would go straight to heaven, instead of chancing 'falling away' as soon as they got up. I mean, that is certainly the SAFEST thing!

I've actually heard that discussion. Just dunk 'em and be done with it. Not seriously, of course, but still.

One would think even discussing this with wry humor would give them pause. If it's that easy to "fall away" and be lost again, maybe there is
something wrong with their interpretation of the bible, God, Christianity.

[Moogy]

My NICOC mother (rest her soul) thought it was unscriptural to have weddings in the church building no matter what music was used. She would not even attend such events. Therefore, my 50-year-old wedding pictures do not show my old COC.

[Shane R]

I remember this quite well. Must have been the mid 90s. Anyhow, there was a wedding at the church (the girl was already pregnant) and there was a boom-box. I don't remember the songs but there were definitely some tunes not of the hymnal.